Friday, August 03, 2007

THE THREAD: SPURR-IOUS ARGUMENTS


So the coaches' poll is out now, and there's very little surprising about the ranks, except the fact that nine voters looked at Florida and said, "Replacing a four-year starter at QB and almost the entire defense? No biggie."


I'll put Florida No. 1 even if only Laura and Barney support me.

The other USC starts out at No. 1, followed by LSU and the Gators. Texas and Michigan round out the top five. West Virginia, Wisconsin, Oklahoma, Virginia Tech and Ohio State are in the top 10. Also of note: Rutgers is No. 16, UCLA is No. 17, and midmajors take 22-24 (TCU, Boise State and Hawaii, respectively.)

Going beyond the official rankings, South Carolina tied Notre Dame for 29th with 90 points, far short of the 209 garnered by No. 25 Texas A&M. Memphis got five points (!) and Kentucky drew one, as did Duke.

Which brings us to a controversy over Steve Spurrier's habit of reserving the 25th spot on his ballot every year for the school that provided his first job as a college head coach. This is using the term "controversy" loosely, because it mostly seems kicked up by USA Today, which trotted out a deputy managing editor to slam one of the voters in a poll run by ... USA Today. Journalists usually don't like to be a part of the story; apparently, USA Today now feels comfortable initiating a story by blasting Spurrier.

Said Jim Welch, USA TODAY deputy managing editor for sports: "It's clear that what once might have seemed quaint has begun to lose its charm. We're hopeful that before next season the coaches association can prevail upon Coach Spurrier to find another way to salute his former team — or that Duke gets better in a hurry."
Grant Teaff, executive director of the American Football Coaches Association, whose members vote in the poll, said Thursday that he plans to discuss the vote with Spurrier.

First, as long as there is one person ranking Memphis No. 21 or several people ranking the Tigers somewhere, C&F would argue that the poll has bigger fish to fry.

Second, seeing as how this is a preseason poll that has little or no bearing on or resemblance to reality, C&F can't imagine what the problem is. If Spurrier were putting Duke No. 1, then there would be a problem. But a tip of his cap to a team that he will remove as soon as it loses -- which, let's face it, should happen the first week of the season -- doesn't damage the "integrity" of the poll.

At least we're aware of Spurrier's vote and the reason for it. For all we know, somebody could be ranking the other USC No. 1 because they like the uniform or making Ohio State No. 10 because, gosh darn it, they just love Jim Tressel's sweatervests.


Nice duds. Here's 16 points.

Preseason polls have little, if any, validity. They're hocus-pocus, a mix of what a team did last year, how many returning starters it has, recruiting, rumor, news reports and scheduling. Actual performance? Eh, not so much -- a key reason C&F would not miss preseason polls if they disappeared.

When Spurrier voting for Duke costs someone a shot at a BCS bowl or a national championship, you've got a point. Until then, it's just sanctimonious whining from someone who obviously takes their poll a lot more seriously than do the rest of us.

Elsewhere:
--The president of the Univeristy of Texas will stand by his Mack, despite the slightly negative publicity generated by a Longhorn crime spree. Brown? He's "disappointed," and apparently at his football students, not just the press.
--Three South Carolina players are leaving or not even joining the team. Dakota Walker and Matt Raysor are bolting for greener pastures while Arkee Smith's appeal fell on deaf ears.
--Ryan Perrilloux is back at LSU. I've got 3-to-1 odds that he gets suspended again.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , ,

3 Comments:

Blogger TideDruid said...

3 cheers for Les Miles, who has proven how ridiculous he really is.

And in a motion of fairness, another cheer for Nick Saban, who got Ryan P. to come to Baton Rouge in the first place.

12:32 AM

 
Blogger Seth said...

Nice blog. I've added your blog to my blog. You can find me at http://hottytoddyblog.blogspot.com (Ole Miss)

12:20 AM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

[p]All of these footwear may be damaged with socks however are specifically intended to end up [url=http://ugguksaleonline.moonfruit.com]ugg uk sale online[/url] employed bare-foot . They can be bought in a wide variety of styles . com/ Related Articles - ugg bailey button short boots, ugg boots uk, ugg bailey button triplet red, [url=http://genuineuggaustralia.moonfruit.com]genuine ugg australia sale[/url] Email this Article to a Friend! Receive Articles like this one direct to your email box!Subscribe for free today! . These last success a cozy gentle critically look developing utilization of your boot . You won't find blue, red, or purple men's shoes . As centuries old shoes based upon Australia, these branded sheepskin boots are solely created from Merino twin faced [url=http://genuinecheapuggboots.moonfruit.com]genuine cheap ugg boots[/url] lambskin, that's considered as the best material to earn ideal winter footwear . Here,we present you our Ultra Short Uggs here.[/p][p]Related Articles - ugg, Email this Article to a Friend! Receive Articles like this one direct to [url=http://uggbootsonlinesaleuk.moonfruit.com]ugg boots online sale uk[/url] your email box!Subscribe for free today! . You will find a healthier [url=http://cheapuggbaileybuttonuk.moonfruit.com]cheap ugg bailey button uk[/url] way . And what better represents excess than $225 boots that look like they were designed for the cast of “Toddlers and Tiaras”? Bridal Uggs are just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to extravagant, unnecessary or just plain scary wedding products and services — just look at the feeding-tube brides profiled recently in the New York Times . Sometimes the price tag on this UGG timeless short-term bootsfor ladies is certainly amazing . And perhaps once they ended up being while in the perfect sector, although elements ended up being likely "good,hair styler, inch they really are sad, overworked, overstressed,ugg boots mini classic, contained around profits employment utilised together were rethinking some time past . Ugg short boots Ugg short boots is designed for supreme convenience . Its supremely soft as well as warm twin-faced sheepskin will accompany you through a warm and comfortable winter.[/p]



[url=http://portomeloxo.com/foro//posting.php?mode=newtopic&f=16&sid=337e8b09fd834696b8497e619cd70a40+Result:+used+self-learning+system+data;+chosen+nickname+%22Robfpb10%22;+success;+BB-code+not+working;]Here Offer the cheap MBT sandals for women online with good quality 3k[/url]
[url=http://www.shodoshima.or.jp/cgi-bin/dengon/fantasy.cgi?%25252B%2525255BPLM=0%2525255D%25252BGET%2525%25255Burl=2Bhttp://www.shodoshima.or.jp/%25255DNimotop+Result:+chosen+nickname+%22Robmwi39%22;+success;+BB-code+not+working;+]There Offer the discount MBT sandals shoes online with good quality 4y[/url]
[url=http://s1.grepoforen.de/166/posting.php?mode=quote&f=2&p=66083++++Result:+chosen+nickname+%22Robguj53%22;+captcha+recognized;+success;+BB-code+not+working;]There Offer the discount MBT sandals for men online with good quality 3i[/url]
[url=http://hrc.forumy.pl/posting.php?mode=quote&f=3&p=50701+++++++++++Result:+chosen+nickname+%22Robzdv37%22;+captcha+recognized;+nofollow+is+found;+success;+BB-code+not+working;]There Offer the cheap MBT sandals for women online with good quality 2u[/url]
[url=http://mtgoscheduler.com/bb3//ucp.php?mode=confirm&confirm_id=9b34b428ab70708e3e16d1e96fe0d963&type=3]There Offer the discount MBT sandals for women online with good quality 4t[/url]

3:18 PM

 

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home